Help me pick an arrow set up

[Cmalone1]

So I just finished up bare shaft tuning a new bow and had two different spine arrows to play with. Here's the specs of each one. Which one would you all suggest?

GT trad .500
28 1/4" long
100 grain brass insert
150 grain point
3-4" feathers

516 grain total weight
22.6% FOC
12 GPP

GT trad .400
30.5" long
100 grain insert
200 grain point
3-4" feathers

609 grains total
24.6% FOC
14.1 GPP

[old_goat2]

Either will do I'm sure, whichever one you shoot better i suppose!

[limbshaker]

What's the draw weight at your draw length?

[Trumpkin the Dwarf]

I'm gonna say the lighter one. Even if you're going after elk. 12 gpp is plenty, and you reach a point of diminishing returns. A little flatter trajectory should help you put the arrow in soft spots more easily.

[Cmalone1]

43 lbs at my draw weight.

[Orion]

12 gpp and overall arrow weight of 516 grains is plenty for deer and you'll get flatter trajectory.