The way I see it the Zwickey and Magnus are the same thing. One is a little softer and has a better warranty but other than that the are identical. When you add the others on the list that are Zwickey copies too they are way out front.  

I use Razorcaps and Phantoms almost interchangeably. I like my heads to be in the 200-225 ranges. My wife uses the 100 grain Phantom along with 100grain inserts.

grizzlies.

I don't change gear very often, been using green razorheads for thirty-five years and occasionally Zwickey Deltas or Snuffers for a little change of pace. All of'em will kill better than I can hunt and I'm really not too bad.                Grant

ttt

ttt

160 gr snuffer w/125 gr adapter.....awesome!!!

zwickeys have killed more deer by laying around the woods and being stepped on than all the others combined

didn't see the Eclipse on there. after a recent hunt in Africa and seeing the business end work from this broad head i like it. they sharpen really easy and stay that way.

4-Blade Eclipse 155  

2-Blade Eclipse 145 or Grizzly 145

Just about any two blade cut on contact head.
Steelforce are my favorite but Grizzlys, Magnus, Zwickys, bears etc. are all excellent broadheads.

-Sharps

I guess based on my past experience it would have to be a zwickey (eskimo or delta).  This year I will be using a Stinger.  I think I know what the stinger will do.  I know I know what the zwickey will do.

Mason and I will be shooting three different heads since we are just starting to hunt with trad stuff. He will try a 125 Phantom 4 blade and Wensel Woodsman. I will try a Simmons Treeshark and a WW.

nocams