3Rivers Archery




The Trad Gang Digital Market














Contribute to Trad Gang and Access the Classifieds!

Become a Trad Gang Sponsor!

Traditional Archery for Bowhunters




RIGHT HAND BOWS CLASSIFIEDS

LEFT HAND BOWS CLASSIFIEDS

TRAD GANG CLASSIFIEDS ACCESS


Main Menu

will it be enough

Started by VinnieB, July 23, 2007, 10:05:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

VinnieB

48#@25" fred bear montana longbow shooting  xx75 2013 arrows tipped with muzzy 3 blade 125 grain broadheads. total arrow weight about 407 grains. will this be enough for deer. i plan on only taking shots 25 yards and in quartering away and broadside.
Martin rebel recurve 45#@25"
Fred Bear Montana Longbow 50#@26"

"Hunting is the last perfect thing"
-Ted Nugent

Jason R. Wesbrock

I think I'd swap out the Muzzys for a cut-on-impact head, but other than that you should be fine, assuming proper tuning.

whitebuffalo

Ya can keep the muzzy as long as that troctar tip is sharp and new, but I would op for a set of new heads.More than anything I think I would bump out those 2013's and get some 2016,2018's to bump up a little weight
TGMM

Landshark160

I agree with Jason, definitely go with a cut on impact head.
Chris
>>>>--------------->

The benefits of a big broadhead are most evident when things go wrong. - CTS

Bow Nut

I'd go heavier and cut-on-impact for penetration. That Montana will handle the job. Good luck!
We cast our best shadow when we stand in the light of 'The Son'

V I Archer

10 grains per pound and a good sharp, cut-on contact head, needle tip slightly blunted.
But be sure you live out the message and do not merely listen to it and so deceive yourself - James 1:22

cjones

The arrow is plenty heavy enough but i would opt for a better broadhead.
Chad Jones

TGMM Family Of The Bow

oldgriz

Got to agree with all above about the broadhead... change out to a good 2 blade cut on impact...
Tom Mullane
Bear Grayling Mag TD 60" 50#
Bear Grayling Mag TD 64" 37#
Wing Chaparell 60" 48#
Tom Cole Old Timer LB 68# 54#

Steertalker

Go with a cut-on-impact 2 blade BH!!!  A Stinger would be great for your setup.
"America is like a healthy body and its resistance is threefold:  its patriotism, its morality and its spiritual like.  If we can undermine these three areas, America will collapse from within."  Joseph Stalin

bjk

The Muzzy is a great head, but at that short a draw and bow weight, I'd opt for a diff BH.  The arrow weight is fine.

Tuning is more important and with a better bh you'll be eating backstraps for sure.

Those Stingers are a nice bh.

Enjoy

Ia Hawkeye

I'd opt for a 2 blade head. If you don't want to sharpen your own, go with a Magnus stinger. Great head !!!

ishiwannabe

Im using a very similar set up(45#, 2016, magnus stinger 125), and the magnus stingers fly great. A cut on contact head will help with penetration, aka passthroughs. Good luck bro.
"I lost arrows and didnt even shoot at a rabbit" Charlie after the Island of Trees.
                        -Jamie

Tajue17

agree or take the blades off the broadhead and sharpen the flat points on a fine diamond stone and that point will shave hair!

but try to get the stinger 2- blade buzz-cuts or something thats cut on contact and razor sharp right from the pack as you might not have a nack at sharpening broadheads just yet and there may be other stuff (like hitting that spot) to worry about so yeah 2- blade stingers--> get a extra set of blades because you'll need to take some shots with these broadheads too..
"Us vs Them"

JEFF B

yup it will do but use cut on contact blades stingers -sonics these are 3 blade and are awesome.
'' sometimes i wake up Grumpy;
other times i let her sleep"

TGMM FAMILY OF THE BOW

jonsimoneau

Get rid of the muzzys and you will be in great shape.  I killed a deer last year with a 46lb. recurve and got complete penetration using an axis shaft and a 2 blade eclipse.  If you are going to use a 3 blade head then I highly recommend a wensel woodsman.  They are the best penetrating 3 blade head out there.

Two Arrows

Good advice from everyone, but I'd personally go with a 4 blade Stinger instead of a two blade. Those Stingers are super sharp, the bleeder blades aren't that big, but I think they will be more help than hinderence to you.
TGMM Family of the Bow

highnoonhunter

Yea,
What they said.
I shot a small forkhorn buck a few years ago with a 40# Shakespeare recurve. I got great penetration with a ribtek and homemade black walnut shafts. I don't know the total arrow weight. All but the feathers on the shaft penetrated the deer.

I feel the ribtek heads may not penetrate like some of the other heads mentioned, just because of thier design. But I feel you shouldn't have a problem with about any cut on contact style head.

hnh
Member: Christian Bowhunters of America
Physically Challenged Bowhunters of America
International Internet Leathercrafters' Guild, Inc.
-
Holmes Mongoose reverse handle longbow. 63" 63@28
Longriver Longbow: 69" 69@28
Kolometz Kustom Longbow 66" 76@28

buckeye_hunter

ummm...what they said.  

Seriously though, I shot a deer with almost exactly the same set up as what your talking about last year(Muzzy three blade 125 grain, overall arrow weight about 425 grains and a 45lb bow).  Unfortunately, the shot was a little off and I did not get much penetration with that set up.  I am switching to a two blade Simmons or Magnus broadhead this year and adding a 100 grain brass insert up front to inrease arrow weight.

Incidentally I saw the same deer several weeks later (non-typical rack)and he looked fine from what I could tell, Thank God.

Charlie

Contact Us | Trad Gang.com © | User Agreement

Copyright 2003 thru 2025 ~ Trad Gang.com ©