If you were to pick a 125 grain broadhead

[JD Page]

You said in your post there fellow Hoosier, Magnus stinger all the way!

[BowArkie]

Simmons land shark

[KyStickbow]

2-blade Magnus Stingers. My favorite head!

[Steelhead]

Another vote for Stinger.I like the price point for the quality.I also really like the diamond tip thats strong and helps to prevent tip curl on bone hits.The ones I have had shave hair out of the package.I shoot the 150 grain 2 blade.

[Wheels2]

Snuffers, if you can find them.  I have four left..

[BRITTMAN]

I always liked the Magnus Stingers , the fly great and have killed everything I've shot with them . No problem with penetration .