Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: trashwood on July 03, 2007, 08:09:00 AM

Title: target v hunting bows??
Post by: trashwood on July 03, 2007, 08:09:00 AM
that is the most interesting aspect of archery equipment and the dichotomy. There is a great deal of cross over toward the middle of things but that leaves a lot of room on each end of things to feed the different camps.

3D shoots have really made the distinction of target vs hunting equipment even more blurred in the states. It is pretty easy identinify a target bow on the FITA field.

Well this kinda interests me. What I'd like to know is do you have a bow that you designate as a target bow (3d, field)? Do you have a bow you call a hunting bow (3d, hunting)? if ya do have different bows would ya tell me about them? draw wieght? lenght? style?  

thanks
rusty
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Dave Coalter on July 03, 2007, 08:21:00 AM
Rusty,
I use the same bow for shooting 3d and for hunting. 50# @ 28" 58" long. I just like the way it shoots and I don't have to try to adjust my shooting style from bow to bow.
Dave
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: longbowman on July 03, 2007, 08:24:00 AM
I nearly shoot my Bear T.D. for all target type shooting.  It's a 70# bow that I can shoot all day very comfortably. When the braodhead tournaments begin in this area, usually near hunting season, I will then do all of my shooting with my 80# longbow or 76# recurve and heavy birch shafts.  I usually shoot about the same scores with all of the bows but the Bear with cedars is so much flatter shooting at the 30-40 yd. targets.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: robtattoo on July 03, 2007, 10:23:00 AM
Hmmmmm. Interesting question.

I have many bows, but only one that I ever use for 3D/field shoots. I've gone the other way from all you guys in that my 3D bow is far heavier than my hunting bows. My hunters are all either 57 or 58#, whereas my 3D bow is 72#

In the UK our field & 3D shoots are at much greater ranges than I'm led to believe they are in the US. I'd say that an average range shot for us is probably 35yds, with targets from 5yds all the way out to 80+ Several ofthe shoots I regularly attend will have at least 20 out of 40 targets at 50yds+ so for me greater cast is pretty important. The faster & therefore flatter my arrow flies, the better chance I have of hitting the looooong targets (furthest I've encountered so far was a 122yd, standing buffalo!)
It takes me a wile to mentally adjust to shooting the lighter hunting bows, but I feel that in a hunting situation, when the adrenaline's pumping & everything's jumpy, a lighter bow makes life easier by far! (plus, they're all take-downs. My 3D bow is a one-piece which makes travelling a real bugger!)
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Orion on July 03, 2007, 10:34:00 AM
I've been shooting 3-D tournaments since they started  Before that we had broadhead shoots, which involved shooting broadheads through cardboard silhouette animal targets.  the arrows passed through and were stopped in a bunker behind the target.  Though I've always enjoyed these shoots, I've always considered them practice for hunting and use my hunting gear exclusively.  In fact, I don't think I have anything that could be classified as target equipment.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: James Wrenn on July 03, 2007, 10:39:00 AM
Same bows with differant arrows.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: xia_emperor on July 03, 2007, 10:41:00 AM
same bow, and arrows
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: mike g on July 03, 2007, 11:06:00 AM
Same Bow and Same Arrows....
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: R H Clark on July 03, 2007, 11:22:00 AM
Right now I shoot a 55 lb Dalaa for everything.I have a DAS Elite 21 inch riser with ILF attachment on order that will be for 3D-target archery only.The Elite will be set up with 40 lb limbs and arrows around 300 grns.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: rbbhunt on July 03, 2007, 11:26:00 AM
I shoot the same bow and arrows.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: longbowman on July 03, 2007, 01:26:00 PM
Robtatto,  I want to come and shoot where you shoot!  I can't stand going to tournaments that make you shoot from what we used to call the kiddy stakes.  Normally I shoot from the compound hunter stakes just to keep it interesting.  Like I said earlier.  I shoot 70# and cedars for most of my 3d shoots but have shot a bunch with my heavier bows.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Mike Byrge@home on July 03, 2007, 07:07:00 PM
Target Bows:
Hoyt PM takedown 25" riser 68" 42@28
Bob Lee long riser 68" 35@28
Wing P1 66" 35@28
Wing P2 68" 33@28

Hunting Bows:
Bob Lee T/D Lb 53# and 57# limbs both 64"
Bob Lee T/d RC 46#, 55# and 60# limbs 60"-64"
Rasmussen Flatbow 64" 55@28
Mild d/r longbow 68" 60@28
Hoyt PM takedown 20" riser 64" 52@28
Sky Hunter supreme 64" 47# and 55# limbs

"Crossover" Bows:
Bob Lee long riser with 46@28 limbs..makes a 64" 42@28 bow. I shoot this combo best and it is what I use if I want a high score.
Hoyt PM 20" riser with 45# limbs. Makes a 64" bow..setup with a plunger and flipper rest.  I'm either very good or very bad with this bow.

My arrows for both hunting and 3d are in the 8-9 grains per pound range or slightly heavier.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: trashwood on July 03, 2007, 07:45:00 PM
I have been tring to learn to shoot lighter draw bows.  I got some 63 yr old orthopedic processes that don't think they are a young as my attitude is.  :)   I thought I might save what was left of them for hunting and use them a little less with lighter 3D/target/small game bows.  

after 40 yr or so of releasing 60# bow strings ya find out your release is stinko big time.  Ya get to learn to shoot all over again or really maybe for the first time  :)

rusty
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Mike Byrge@home on July 03, 2007, 09:31:00 PM
Forgot about my favorite target bow...Wing Competition 2 - 68" 35@28

I too have a hard time getting off the string with anything below the low 40#s.  When my form is good and I'm focused I shoot light bows very well.  When I'm having a bad day though I have arrows all over the place.

I shot an indoor 300 league last year and would alternate between my 57# Lee and one of my target bows.  My scores with my hunting bow were all between 223 and the low 230's with a a 227 average.  With my target bows I shot a low of a 208 and a high of 250 and averaged close to 230.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Van/TX on July 03, 2007, 09:36:00 PM
No comment  ;)   Sure glad to see ya posting though, Rusty.  I might stop in more often if this keeps up  :biglaugh:  ...Van
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Jason R. Wesbrock on July 04, 2007, 12:21:00 AM
My primary interest in archery is bowhunting, so I do all my target shooting with the same bow and arrows I hunt with (minus broadheads). If my goal was to shoot the highest target scores I could, I'd trade my 60" 57# hunting bow for a 68" low-40's FITA recurve shooting 300-grain arrows.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: cjones on July 04, 2007, 12:57:00 AM
UI have always shot targets with the same bow i hunt with. I do plan on having a dedicated target bow soon though. I try to keep all my bows right at 50#@29".
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: gordie on July 04, 2007, 07:03:00 AM
i'm with van
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: John Havard on July 04, 2007, 09:23:00 AM
Hi Rusty,

As you probably know I own quite a few bows and love all of them.  As the owner of one of David's first master hunter bows and with an elite on order and owning 4-5 sets of FITA limbs I obviously appreciate his ideas for blending the two genres of shooting bows.  

However, I have gravitated toward one bow for both activities that allows me to do both quite well.  I normally shoot my camo ACS Apogee with a variety of limb weights in lengths of either 66" or 68" (31" draw length).  I find that by blending my shooting style for both indoor winter targets and September moose hunting I do both better in my estimation. Stable metal risers, elevated rests, and practicing out to 80 yards are all good things for both target shooting as well as for improving hunting accuracy.

I'd be shooting my 57# limbs on my Apogee this weekend in a Wisconsin field archery meet were it not for minor arthroscopic knee surgery on Friday morning.

While I'm no accomplished target archer like you and several of your acquaintances (congratulations on your recent successes!), I do okay in the competitive arena (I compete in a fairly small pond).  I like blending the two capabilities into one bow personally.  And you're dead right about how a lighter bow will force you to work on cleaning up your release!
John
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: John D on July 04, 2007, 11:30:00 AM
My bow I use for field archery is a 1966 Kodiak Special 40# with my draw lenght I'm pulling 38#. I shoot barebow off the shelf with Easton 1913s with 9% nib points. with this bow I dont wear out shooting a 112 arrows on a 28 target, field and hunter round.

My hunting bows are A BlackWidow 55#-60" T-D and a Bear T-D 50#-60" 2117s with 145gr points or broadheads.I have no problem when I switch to the heavier bows. I also think the lighter bow will force you to work on better form and a cleaner release! jmo
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: wingnut on July 04, 2007, 11:34:00 AM
Well after a shoulder injury this winter my target and hunting bow is a 47# BushWacker shooting 2016 with Woodsmans upfront for hunting and cedar arrows for shoots.

I'm glad this bow will produce as well as it does because I still struggle with anything heavier.

Mike
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Big Dave on July 04, 2007, 06:25:00 PM
Same bow and arrows  :thumbsup:    :thumbsup:
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: trashwood on July 04, 2007, 10:49:00 PM
thanks for the input guys.  

It will be interesting to watch the tradbow design over the next few yrs as the baby boomer drop their draw weight since it seems like a lot of tradbow hunters are in the babyboomer generation.  I was shooting with some fellows last weekend that were 10 yrs or so older than me (i'm 63 soon 64).  A number of them still hunted but the bow draw weight had been replaced with accuracy  :) ....adn some 'em geezer could shoot  :)

rusty
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Adam Keiper on July 04, 2007, 11:15:00 PM
I'm pretty much with Jason.  I like to set up all my bows for hunting, with as heavy a draw weight and as heavy an arrow as I can manage well.  (Though, I do have a few bows that didn't make weight and are in the high 40's to mid 50's.)  I'm not interested in scores, per say.  I just want to be able to accurately shoot heavy gear that will slap monkey snot out of anything I encounter.

For a couple rounds of arrows, I really don't see a difference in accuracy between light and heavy setups.  It's only when I start shooting repeated ends at the butts where fatigue takes its toll.
Title: Re: target v hunting bows??
Post by: Straitshot on July 05, 2007, 09:00:00 AM
Ditto, Big Dave.