Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: Slickhead on March 11, 2018, 06:17:00 PM

Title: arrow recommendation
Post by: Slickhead on March 11, 2018, 06:17:00 PM
Im switching t a 40 lb rd hybrid longbow.I hunt whitetail and occasional small game.
any recommendations for arrow and broadhead?
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: Fletcher on March 11, 2018, 08:47:00 PM
What is your arrow length, bow make and model and depth of shelf cut?  Do you have a preference for wood, alum or carbon?
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: Gdpolk on March 11, 2018, 09:12:00 PM
I've been extremely pleased with Grizzly broadheads.  With a 40lb bow I would stick with any reputable 2-blade.  I would recommend one with a more narrow cut and longer point for better efficiency, whether it's a Grizzly or not.  I like single bevels better than double bevels but a double bevel isn't going to prevent you from killing anything that you hit properly so I wouldn't get super caught up on that if you prefer Zwickeys or magnus or VPA or any of the other exceptional heads out there.  Just make sure they are sharp.

As for arrow, I would get the one that tunes properly for you and your bow.  I'm not trying to cop out but that's the honest truth.  I prefer carbons because they are more durable in my experience and allow me to do more stuff with point weights.

If you go carbons would reccomend doing small game arrows with 125gr points and bringing up your overall point weight with weighted inserts as needed to match your broadheads.  By doing this you can use 125gr field points, screw in rubber blunts, steel small game hunting blunts, screw in Judo points, AND 125gr broadheads for small game.  This versatility is a HUGE advantage for the small game hunter as every situation calls for a slightly different build.  Then on your "deer" arrows or other medium sized game animals put as much weight in the broadhead as you can and use lighter inserts to match the overall insert/point weights on your small game shafts.  Doing this lets you beef up your bladed broadheads for improved durability and larger heads with better geometries without messing with your overall point weights.

For example, my quiver has the following build types all of which are within +/-4 grains of each other on my scale and shoot to the exact same point of impact.  All are built on Gold Tip Traditional shafts, but I could have done a similar build with a plethora of other shafts just as well.  My batch of arrows for my main bow is 3.5 dozen and I just grab and go with whatever I need for a given situation:
 
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: Roy from Pa on March 11, 2018, 09:17:00 PM
Excellent reply, Garrett.

X's 2
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: the rifleman on March 11, 2018, 09:49:00 PM
Try the heritage 75s.  They spine .675, have good weight and work well out of my 40# Whip.  Begin w full length and tune according to ultimate broadhead weight youre after.  Stick to 10 gpp and sharp 2 blade and youll be fine.  Unless you draw past 28 and / or your bos is cut past center 600 s will likely be too stiff.  I believe axis makes a 700 also that should work.  Good luck.
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: acedoc on March 11, 2018, 10:13:00 PM
Buy the weakest spine Beman bowhunters,  tune with point weight and shelf. They are inexpensive and tough
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: Roy from Pa on March 11, 2018, 10:47:00 PM
Depending on how close to center the shelf is cut, a light spine arrow out of a 40 pound bow should work. Being cut closer to center does a lot to reduce the paradox issues in tuning a bow.

The broadhead will be up to you, all ya need is one with the same weight as the field points you tune the bow with.

Just have fun and enjoy the journey..
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: Michael K Miller on March 11, 2018, 10:54:00 PM
X2 on CE Heritage shafts and zwickey deltas are my choice in BH
Title: Re: arrow recommendation
Post by: Slickhead on March 12, 2018, 08:15:00 AM
looking at using carbon (never have from a trad bow)
But I may give them a shot