Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: Bud B. on January 13, 2018, 11:03:00 PM

Title: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 13, 2018, 11:03:00 PM
Weapons (SC)
3.1 – On WMA lands hunters may use any shotgun, rifle, bow and arrow, crossbow or hand gun except specific weapons may be prohibited on certain hunts. Small game hunters may possess or use shotguns with shot no larger than No. 2 or .22 or smaller rimfire rifles/handguns or primitive muzzle-loading rifles of .40 caliber or smaller. Small game hunters may not possess or use buckshot, slugs or shot larger than No. 2. Blow guns, dart guns, drugged arrows or arrows with exploding tips are not permitted. Small game hunters using archery equipment must use small game tips on the arrows (judo points, bludgeon points, etc.).

http://www.dnr.sc.gov/regs/wmaregs.html#weapons


So, a fella planning to go hunt hogs on WMAs during small game seasons cannot carry broadheads?

Any SC Wildlife officers on here?

Are the same point restrictions listed in/for Georgia WMAs?
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 13, 2018, 11:20:00 PM
Based on this, I take it Ga allows broadheads for hogs during small game seasons on WMAs.


https://law.justia.com/codes/georgia/2010/title-27/chapter-3/article-1/part-1/27-3-4

Man I wish the regs in all states were more clearly written.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: David McLendon on January 14, 2018, 12:17:00 AM
Broadheads are required for hogs during small game season in Georgia.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Nantahala Nut on January 14, 2018, 08:40:00 AM
South Carolina is so confusing with their hunting laws. Needlessly complicated. Thanks for bringing this to my attention. I was looking at hunting hogs during small game near the Savannah
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: David McLendon on January 14, 2018, 10:16:00 AM
Tuckahoe WMA was my favorite WMA for hogs, about 17-18 miles on the Savannah River and some land along Brier Creek. We used to take a lot of hogs there, where the hogs are is usually where the gators are as well. Snake chaps aren't a bad thing to have and when it storms, water comes up high and fast around Brier Creek.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 14, 2018, 01:37:00 PM
Thanks David. I have been eyeing Tuckahoe. Did you camp or motel stay?
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Jeff D. Holchin on January 14, 2018, 01:51:00 PM
Broadheads are legal on GA WMAs
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Jeff D. Holchin on January 14, 2018, 01:52:00 PM
Broadheads are legal in GA WMAs during small game Season
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Possum Head on January 14, 2018, 02:09:00 PM
Though you didn't inquire of Mississippi's regs. for the sake of discussion I'll include it's the same here, only small game heads during small game only season. Turkey being another matter as broad heads are legal for Turkeys you can pursue pigs during that season. A lot of discussion concerning this has come up lately in our ranks. Seems if hogs were so invasive every opportunity to kill them would be made available.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 14, 2018, 05:21:00 PM
QuoteOriginally posted by Possum Head:
Though you didn't inquire of Mississippi's regs. for the sake of discussion I'll include it's the same here, only small game heads during small game only season. Turkey being another matter as broad heads are legal for Turkeys you can pursue pigs during that season. A lot of discussion concerning this has come up lately in our ranks. Seems if hogs were so invasive every opportunity to kill them would be made available.
Another case where law abiding citizens (hunters) suffer due to the criminal conduct, or potential criminal conduct of others (poachers). I would not use a small game head on a hog or a coyote. But taking a .22lr or .22 mag into the same woods is apparently legal. More deer fall to poaching by those two calibers than do by broadheads, I would wager.

In NC you can take broadheads onto gamelands in small game season.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Matt Quick on January 14, 2018, 07:18:00 PM
Check the SC regs carefully when you plan your hunt. Many WMA's have scheduled dog gun hunts during Feb and March. I can't imagine being down there during those if your trying to bowhunt. Good luck.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: David McLendon on January 14, 2018, 07:35:00 PM
Bud we camped there, they had campsites available on the area with shower facilities. We used to have a group of 8-10 and great times but it's been a good while since I was there. If you go there take plenty of food for camp, or do like we usually did and the first deer was camp meat, because there is not a lot nearby in the way of places to eat, that may have changed but I doubt it.
It was a good area and we hunted both deer and hogs there with good success, just watch out for the rattlers. The biggest Eastern Diamondback that I have ever personally seen was sunning there one cold morning. Thing about Tuckahoe is that even in the dead of winter it'll warm up enough a lot of days for the crawly things to come out.
Our first hunt there firearms were legal and I showed up with my longbow. It was a tough hunt weather wise and I was the only one to take a hog. Next trip there were more bows, and then they started shedding wheels after that. at the end of the run of about 5 years, 6 guys had become traditional bowhunters, two of which had not previously been archers at all.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 14, 2018, 07:35:00 PM
I am not going to any SC WMAs during small game season. Not until they change that law.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Possum Head on January 14, 2018, 08:00:00 PM
QuoteOriginally posted by Bud B.:
 
QuoteOriginally posted by Possum Head:
Though you didn't inquire of Mississippi's regs. for the sake of discussion I'll include it's the same here, only small game heads during small game only season. Turkey being another matter as broad heads are legal for Turkeys you can pursue pigs during that season. A lot of discussion concerning this has come up lately in our ranks. Seems if hogs were so invasive every opportunity to kill them would be made available.
Another case where law abiding citizens (hunters) suffer due to the criminal conduct, or potential criminal conduct of others (poachers). I would not use a small game head on a hog or a coyote. But taking a .22lr or .22 mag into the same woods is apparently legal. More deer fall to poaching by those two calibers than do by broadheads, I would wager.

In NC you can take broadheads onto gamelands in small game season. [/b]
Good point Bud
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: TradBrewSC on January 14, 2018, 08:10:00 PM
Bud, as I read, this is referring only to small game hunters, and designed simply to keep squirrel hunters from slinging broadheads a country mile.

Come down and kill all of the hogs you want. You are reading into it too much. If approached by a DNR officer, simply tell them you are hog hunting and I feel confident that little regard will be paid towards your equipment.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 14, 2018, 08:28:00 PM
I will call, first. SC's fees went outta sight for out of staters. I used to buy an annual license. Not any more.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Nantahala Nut on January 14, 2018, 08:35:00 PM
Ive heard there are hogs on Warwoman and swallow creek in the northeast. Also supposed to be a lot on Beaverdam WMA in the south central part.  Maybe some guys with some local knowledge can point us in the right direction.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 14, 2018, 08:46:00 PM
They are along the Waccamaw, too. Just south of NC line.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 14, 2018, 08:55:00 PM
Good to know, David. Thank you for your insight and reply.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: bluemelonchitlin on January 14, 2018, 09:08:00 PM
For those of you from NC wanting to hunt SC hogs-Hogback Mountain in Northern Greenville County is loaded with pigs.
I spoke eith a DNR officer years ago about hog hunts year round and the use of broadheads. She told me broadheads are illegal unless it's turkey or deer season. When I questioned her about why pigs can be hunted year round but broadheads can't be used all she said is it's the law stupid as it is.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: tradarcher816 on January 15, 2018, 07:25:00 AM
Last time I inquired of dnr broadheads were a big "no no" in SC during small game season. Was a big bummer when I found out.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 15, 2018, 08:19:00 AM
For those not aware, SC has made it more expensive to hunt WMAs and big game for those of us out of state. Ga. has made it less expensive for out of staters. When buying a Ga basic license you now automatically get their WMA access pass.

I am sure SC has their reasons, but hunting hogs on WMAs in SC during small game with a bow and by their regulations is quite unethical to me.

Has the PBS or any other national bowhunting organization tried to educate them on how a broadhead is more way ethical on hogs than a judo?
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Cory Mattson on January 15, 2018, 08:49:00 AM
Quick point about SC - (stump shooting) with a Judo on Wildlife Management Areas or Heritage Trust Preserves is illegal. This is considered "target Practice" and as such is not allowed. I have a written warning 1992 as proof and the fine runs $450. Yes many "game wardens" have no clue of things wildlife and hunting!

Guys there is a laundry list of why SC should not be your choice for off season hog hunts. Read Matt Quicks post again. Look at the length of gun seasons and compare these dates to supposed "bow" seasons.  

SC does have a few decent public land bow hunts for hogs September / early October time frame if you are willing to work hard AND buy the expensive licenses required.

Lots of guys from other states think that because hogs are destructive landowners and game agencies are waiting to "point you in the right direction" or "invite you for free" --- NO that ain't happening. The reality is hogs are Trapped - Caught and killed with Dogs - and shot with Rifles year round on all the private land that borders these WMAs.

<><
<-------------<<<<<<
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 15, 2018, 09:53:00 AM
I wrote the commissioners of SCDNR.

I am not an eloquent writer, but here it is:

SCDNR Commissioners,
Greetings,

Over the past six years I have made an annual trek to Estill, SC to hunt a place called Wild Things near Cohen's Bluff along the Savannah River.  Andrew Harper was the owner and proprietor of the hunting location.  The primary draw to Wild Things was the opportunity to hunt feral hogs with a bow and arrow.  All who hunted Andrew's land couldn't help but to fall in love with the low country swamps and timber lands of South Carolina.  Sadly, Andrew drowned at Hilton Head in August of 2017 in a rip tide current.  Hunting at Wild Things for now continues but its distant future is uncertain. Hopefully Wild Things hunting will continue with Andrew's strong and supportive family.

Andrew's death prompted me to investigate other opportunities for feral hog hunting in SC.  I am an avid supporter of public lands and began to investigate the hunting of feral hogs on SC's vast Wildlife Management Areas.  I learned that while the hunting of feral hog (and coyote) are allowed on WMAs during SC's small game season, I was truly disappointed to learn that the use of broadheads during this season was not allowed.  Only small game heads can be used. To quote the regulation, "Small game hunters using archery equipment must use small game tips on the arrows (judo points, bludgeon points, etc.)." I find this puzzling.  I also find that if SCDNR wants hunters to use "judo points, bludgeon points, etc." the expectation is quite unethical.  A quick and humane kill is the goal of all ethical bowhunters. A sharp well placed broadhead is how this is achieved.

I realize that the primary purpose of this stipulation in the law may be to deter poachers from shooting deer, but, if the allowance of the use of a .22 long rifle cartridge or .22 magnum rimfire cartridge is legal during small game season, would not a person prone to poaching use this weapon (rifle or pistol) to poach as well?  I believe this particular restriction within the law greatly reduces the number of bowhunters that may otherwise come to SC to hunt feral hogs. Bowhunters equate to license sales, gasoline purchases, food purchases, motel stays, and so on.

My purpose of writing this letter is to prompt discussion among your group. I trust you have received this with an open mind and with the willingness to ask questions to each other and to hunters, particularly bowhunters, in your own state.  I know many out of state bowhunters would love to see this law changed so that we may cross your borders, enjoy the beautiful landscape of South Carolina, and help eradicate, hopefully, an invasive species of animal. Our revenue awaits this change. Allowing broadheads for hogs during small game season will open the door for more hunters to SC and promote an inviting atmosphere to us legal and ethical bowhunters.

Most respectfully,
Charles T. Blaylock, Jr.
Asheboro, NC

If any of you are so inclined to write-

Norman@pulliaminvestment.com, willise@dnr.sc.gov,
yoncel@dnr.sc.gov,
keith@wacclt.com
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: David McLendon on January 15, 2018, 10:02:00 AM
If hunting specifically for hogs on GA WMA's I would bypass the northern areas and concentrate on areas in the lower piedmont and coastal plain like Tuckahoe, Beaverdam and Oaky Woods.
My #1 pick would be Ft Stewart by a long shot, there are a few hoops to jump through as far as getting a permit but well worth it.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Nantahala Nut on January 15, 2018, 11:06:00 AM
This has been a great educational thread. Thanks bud for taking the time to advocate on behalf of bow hunters. Seems stupid that guys can go plink 22 at hogs but we can't shoot a broadhead. I'm really looking at Georgia now. Most of the south central wmas are about 4 hours for me.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: WESTBROOK on January 15, 2018, 05:55:00 PM
QuoteOriginally posted by David McLendon:
Tuckahoe WMA was my favorite WMA for hogs, about 17-18 miles on the Savannah River and some land along Brier Creek. We used to take a lot of hogs there, where the hogs are is usually where the gators are as well. Snake chaps aren't a bad thing to have and when it storms, water comes up high and fast around Brier Creek.
Tuckahoe is straight across the river from Wild Things
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 15, 2018, 06:17:00 PM
Yes. Directly across.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Jeff D. Holchin on January 15, 2018, 07:09:00 PM
So for GA, the annual $75 WMA license is no longer required?  I second Ft Stewart as a great hog hunt destination, even now that you have to qualify to bowhunt.  Lots of hogs and they even have a campground with showers that is pretty cheap.

I lived in SC twice and saw that bowhunters are not well regarded there, as evidenced by their public land regs. GA is much more bowhunter friendly and so now I drive right thru SC to get to a state that has much better bowhunting opportunities and a lower cost.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: David McLendon on January 15, 2018, 07:40:00 PM
After doing a little online reading, it looks as though as of last year that Ft Stewart may have done away with archery qualification.
I had to shoot at least 2 out of 3 at 20 & 30 yards in a 9 inch target last time I hunted there, it was a pie plate test and was not a big deal.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Possum Head on January 16, 2018, 07:56:00 PM
Yes good job on the letter Bud, couldn't have said it any better. Mississippi thinks rubber blunts are the go to pig head obviously.   :dunno:
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Blaino on January 17, 2018, 11:37:00 AM
Hey Bud.  This is something that I've been p'd off about for quite some time!!!  I have done the same as you and wrote letters and made phone call, the response I've got has been less then supportive! Multiple DNR represnetives have stated that the rules aren't written to benefit bowhunters. It was written that the hunter chasing squirrels and rabbits who comes across a pig can "lawfully" kill that animal, and it's up the individual hunter to decide what is "humane".... Also, I can't for the life of me understand why "they" are trapping hogs on public land and not letting the HUNTER control the population with less restrictions and more opportunities for a HUNTER.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 17, 2018, 11:42:00 AM
We need to bomb them with emails and maybe there will be a change.

Still no acknowledgement of my email.

Phone calls are next.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Blaino on January 18, 2018, 08:22:00 AM
I'd be surprised if you hear anything back.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Liquid Amber on January 20, 2018, 08:26:00 AM
"Also, I can't for the life of me understand why "they" are trapping hogs on public land and not letting the HUNTER control the population."

Hogs cannot be controlled by legal, daylight hunting methods, that's why.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Liquid Amber on January 20, 2018, 08:29:00 AM
I should have stated "with out" dogs.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 20, 2018, 08:53:00 AM
If I have read the SC regs correctly, "drives" are illegal also.
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Blaino on January 20, 2018, 02:20:00 PM
QuoteOriginally posted by Liquid Amber:
"Also, I can't for the life of me understand why "they" are trapping hogs on public land and not letting the HUNTER control the population."

Hogs cannot be controlled by legal, daylight hunting methods, that's why.
They could start by letting bowhunters use broadheads after deer season, letting gun hunters use a centerfire rifle, and never closing the season.
Also, they do have dog hunts...
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Blaino on January 26, 2018, 10:20:00 AM
Bud - Have you got any kind of response?
Title: Re: South Carolina and Georgia WMA Hunters
Post by: Bud B. on January 27, 2018, 01:24:00 PM
None. I wrote about 16 of the state legislators. Nothing but automated replies. 1st column down. Two more columns to go.

Emailing them from here:
https://www.scstatehouse.gov/email.php?chamber=B